Airports of Shelter Island Closest ariports to Shelter Island city: East Hampton Airport (distance 15.3 km / 9.5 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets Griswold Airport (distance 32 km / 19.9 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets Elizabeth Field Airport (distance 39.3 km / 24.4 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets Suffolk County Airport (distance 40.5 km / 25.2 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets New London Airport (distance 42.7 km / 26.5 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets Montauk Airport (distance 45.9 km / 28.5 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets Peconic River Airport (distance 52 km / 32.3 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets New Haven Airport (distance 63.9 km / 39.7 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets Brookhaven Airport (distance 64 km / 39.8 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets Westerly State Airport (distance 66.3 km / 41.2 mi) | ✈️ Book tickets Airports of Shelter Island city on map: ☞ Show Map Find air tickets to Shelter Island airport